The Spanish economist and YouTuber Antonini de Jiménez offered a compelling critique of Cuba during a conference at the Centro Ricardo Salinas Pliego in Mexico. He outlined the reasons why he would never visit the island nation.
In a video shared on his TikTok account, Antonini remarked, "Life expectancy in Cuba is certainly high, and there seems to be universal access to education and healthcare, well..." However, he quickly pointed out that the real issue lies in the lack of freedom. "Even if Cuba were the best country in the world, hypothetically, I wouldn't go because there's no freedom. Education becomes mere instruction. What's the point of living longer if you have to live like an animal... if all you can do is obey?" he stated, delivering a sharp critique of the island's governance.
Antonini went on to say that "all those economic, social, and cultural indicators lose their significance if they don't have the muscle of freedom behind them." His remarks sparked numerous comments and discussions about the current reality in Cuba, with several Cubans expressing their agreement.
One user noted, "Life expectancy is high in Cuba because the current elderly were the last to experience capitalism in Cuba. Just wait for the next generation." Another person added, "They offer you free healthcare and education in exchange for your freedom and for not thinking about an alternative system... No thanks, I prefer freedom and am willing to pay for my health and education."
A different user criticized the notion of free healthcare in Cuba, stating, "Healthcare in Cuba hasn't been free for a long time. If you need surgery, you have to buy everything yourself and pay to expedite the procedure."
Antonini's social media and YouTube content focuses on individual freedom and critiques state intervention. He delves into ethical values, censorship, and the complacency he believes characterizes modern society.
Antonini de Jiménez's Critique of Cuba
Here are some frequently asked questions and answers about Antonini de Jiménez’s views on Cuba and the broader implications of his critique.
Why does Antonini de Jiménez refuse to visit Cuba?
Antonini de Jiménez refuses to visit Cuba primarily due to the lack of freedom. He argues that despite high life expectancy and access to education, the absence of freedom diminishes the value of these achievements.
What does Antonini think about Cuba's education system?
Antonini believes that in Cuba, education becomes mere instruction due to the lack of freedom. He argues that true education requires the freedom to think independently.
How do Cubans respond to Antonini's critique?
Many Cubans agree with Antonini's views. They highlight issues like the conditional nature of "free" healthcare and education, and prefer freedom over state-provided services.